Let me just say it plainly: Spider-Man: Brand New Day is the best thing the MCU has done with Peter Parker, and it earns that by genuinely not being afraid to let him suffer. The whole premise picks up directly from No Way Home. The world doesn't remember Peter exists. His friends have moved on. He's just a guy in a suit, alone, fighting crime full-time in a city that can't even thank him because it has no idea who he is.
The loneliness is not just set dressing here. It is the movie. Cretton, who directed Shang-Chi and before that quietly brilliant dramas like Short Term 12 and Just Mercy, brings that same character-first instinct to a $200 million superhero film and it actually works. He keeps the focus on Peter even when the movie is pulling in six different directions with new additions and cameos. Reviewers are already calling this Holland's best Peter Parker performance across all four films, and honestly it is not a hard case to make.
The cast is stacked but Sadie Sink is the one everyone's going to be talking about. She plays a mysterious antagonist whose abilities involve telepathic mind control, and she's electric in it. Reviews are describing her as the most inspired MCU casting since Holland himself landed the role. There's something about the way Cretton has used her here that feels like it actually matters for where the MCU is going, with her character signaling the arrival of mutants in a way that doesn't feel like a press release announcement. It feels earned.
Jon Bernthal's Frank Castle is exactly what the Punisher has always needed, a violent, gritty wildcard who still manages to be weirdly funny when placed next to a kid in red spandex. The odd-couple energy between him and Holland is genuinely one of the best things in the movie. Mark Ruffalo shows up as Bruce Banner, now teaching college physics, and gets a proper Hulk-out moment that reviewers are saying lands better than any of his recent appearances.
The film broke the all-time preview record with $72 million before it even officially opened, beating Avengers: Endgame. That number tells you something about the demand, but the 91 percent on Rotten Tomatoes tells you the movie actually delivers. It is not flawless. Some critics have pointed out the script feels overstuffed, with The Hand and a few side characters coming and going without much weight. But the core emotional story never loses the thread.
If you're going in, I'd rewatch No Way Home first. The emotional weight of Brand New Day depends on you feeling the full cost of that spell. Peter made a sacrifice and this movie makes sure you never forget what it actually took from him.
No comments yet